|
The Science Behind RealContacts
Abstract
RealContacts is a web and email based service based on the evolving science of "Small World Networks."
The service helps you communicate with your extended personal and business network of contacts and
accomplish things while preserving privacy. The first application helps you find staff or jobs,
and other applications are in development. This paper summarizes the background science and outlines the
new way that RealContacts uses the Internet to improve the efficiency of communications within extended social networks.
Introduction
RealContacts is an unusual blend of business and science. Our team has primarily
a business background, and our main focus has been to create a service that
people will find useful and valuable. However, the product's overall architecture
and design has been heavily influenced by the emerging science of "Small
World Networks." The aim of this paper is to give a brief outline of the
science behind RealContacts. The key scientific ideas are outlined in a very
cursory way - just enough to set the scene as to what we are attempting to do
with RealContacts. There are a number of references at the end of the paper
that do a much better job of explaining the science in detail.
Background Science
Six Degrees of Separation
In the mid 1960s sociologist Stanley Milgram from Harvard University carried
out a series of famous experiments tracking how letters with no address sent
to random parts of the US made their way though networks of people back to the
sender. The average number of steps required to get back to the recipient was
less than 6, and interestingly the majority went via 2 highly connected contacts
of the recipient. From this Milgram developed what he called the "Small
World Hypothesis," which said, in effect, that everyone was connected to
everyone else by six degrees or less. Later, the famous Six Degrees of Kevin
Bacon online game site made the idea popular, by linking all Hollywood actors
to Kevin Bacon based on films they had made together.
Strength of Weak Ties
In 1973 Mark Granovetter published a classic paper called "The Strength
of Weak Ties," that analyzed how people found jobs. He found that most
people - about 56 percent - found their job through a personal contact.
The most surprising results were:
- Only 16% of people found jobs through a contact they saw "often"
(close friend or family)
- 84% got their job through a contact they saw "occasionally" or
"rarely"
A key reason for these results is that the people you know well are likely
to also know each other and therefore know about the same opportunities. It
is the people who you interact with infrequently who are likely to know about
different opportunities, and hence be the most valuable contacts for finding
a job. This research highlighted that the weak ties between people are very
important in linking people within larger social networks.
Small World Theory
In 1996 Cornell University Graduate student Duncan Watts was working on the
question of how fireflies and other animals synchronize bursts of light or sound.
He began studying computer models of networks with his doctoral supervisor,
Steve Strogatz. They found out that adding just a few random links to an otherwise
clustered network dramatically lowers the degree of separation between nodes.
This relatively small change in the way a network is connected makes a dramatic
improvement in the efficiency of information transfer.
This subtle, simple mathematical network pattern has been found to exist in
such diverse networks as:
- Power grids
- Food webs for ecosystems
- The way words are linked in sentences
- The structure of the Internet
- Neurons in the brain
- The nervous system of worms
Science author Mark Buchanan noted, "These networks turned out to have
almost exactly the same small-world structure as the social worlds. For some
mysterious reason, Watts and Stragatz's odd-looking graphs seemed to be pointing
towards some deep organizing principle of our world." This elegant finding
by Watts and Strogatz, summarized in a 1998 paper in Nature titled, "Collective
Dynamics of 'Small World' Networks," has stimulated a vast amount of subsequent
research.
Small Worlds Theory,
the Internet, and RealContacts
The Small Worlds Theory applies at three main levels on the Internet:
- The mechanics of information flows through hardware networks of computers
and routers. Bill Cheswick of Bell Laboratories and Hal Birch of Carnegie
Mellon University pioneered the mapping of these physical connections and
have produced some spectacular images of the Internet.
- The network of information links (URLs) among web pages via the World Wide
Web. This is quite different from the network pattern of physical flows of
information. Albert-László Barabási and his colleagues
at Notre Dame University built a computer "robot" to wander the
web and map these connections. This research led to the identification of
other generic rules about the mathematics of small worlds that emphasized
the importance of hubs and how they influence the robustness of networks.
- The flow of information between individuals, primarily through email and
web pages. Again this is different from the physical flows of information
or the way web pages are linked to each other. It is about the way information
travels in social networks using the Internet as a tool. This is the main
area of interest for RealContacts. Our aim is to set up a tool that uses the
Internet to allow easier communication within social networks.
At the moment there is an information glut in the world. The current environment
is creating so much information noise that we can barely cope. We are constantly
bombarded with ideas, information, and advertising from various media, and the
global reach of the Internet is accelerating this. As the volume goes up we
need even more advanced filters, and one of the key ways people filter information
is to get it from people they know.
We value information from people we know more than that from people we don't
know, but the way that valued information is transferred at the moment is ad-hoc
and time consuming. The aim of RealContacts is to build a tool that allows information
flows between groups of trusted people to be easier for everyone involved.
RealContacts operates as a type of router or filter for information in your
extended social network. It shields you from the unreliable information and
lets in pre-qualified, quality information. More importantly it allows you to
find out about things that are not available to the general public. It does
this not by requiring complex "rules" to filter information coming
from the general public, but by simply admitting only the information coming
from people you know, and the people they know, and so on out to a controllable
number of degrees. Because users have total control over who they choose to
be connected to, the personal networks are self regulating.
Rules that have guided the design of RealContacts
Starting with the background theory we came up with a few basic design rules
for RealContacts:
- You (the user) must have total control over the information flows and you
get to change this by deciding who you are connected to, what type of information
you are interested in, and how deep in the network you want to disseminate
and view or be notified of information
- You cannot get different information than you might otherwise get from normal
social interaction. The process is simply more efficient and less hassle for
everyone involved
- Your privacy is totally protected. For example, no other user can see who
your personal contacts are, yet information can still flow in the social network.
Lots of different types of information can flow within the social network
without the need to rebuild your social network each time.
- It has to be as much like your normal social interactions as possible
We chose to implement RealContacts using standard web application and database
components. One open standard protocol initiative for definition of social network
information and exchange of that information is underway, called FOAF (Friend
of a Friend). However, we have not yet pursued the use of FOAF primarily because
of our focus on the privacy of our users. We are firmly of the opinion that
while people are keen to share information via their network of contacts, most
people do not want to share details of who their contacts are. We believe that
any system that does share personal contact information will only appeal to
a small subset of people, who are willing to sacrifice their privacy and that
of their contacts in order to meet more contacts. However, an open and secure
protocol for user controlled exchange of social network information is an attractive
objective, but only if all the users involved (not only the initiator) are protected
and are assumed to "opt-out" of information exchange by default. This
is a complex issue, and we prefer to focus for the time being on a complete
application platform with strong privacy protection.
Practical Applications of a RealContacts
Network
Although these are interesting ideas we know that people will not use a web
service unless they have a compelling reason in their personal or business life.
SixDegrees.com, the most well known early web site to illustrate the Six Degrees
of Separation for individual users, highlighted that relying on the curiosity
appeal of the phenomenon without compelling and easy to use applications is
not sufficient for success. We have designed RealContacts so that people have
a strong specific reason to use the service and full control over who is able
to see their information and interact with them.
If these ideas are as important as we think then they should help solve real
everyday issues for people. Of the scores of potential ideas to start off with
we identified finding a partner and finding a job as two things that are important
and at the same time reliant on personal networks.
FriendlyConnections.net
Note: this service is not currently available online to the general public.
Our first application was in 2001, when we built the web site friendlyconnections.net
to allow people to meet people and find dates through their extended network
of contacts. One of the key reasons we started with dating was that most people
in long-term relationships seem to have met through mutual friends. While the
mechanics of this service worked well and there were some successes the main
obstacle was people's resistance to being involved with Internet dating.
RealContacts Jobs Application
Finding jobs or staff is a much more appealing application for the following
reasons:
- There is none of the social stigma attached with dating. The fear of being
seen to be job-hunting is overcome through tight protection of privacy and
identity.
- People know that finding a great job or staff often happens through networks
of contacts and both employers and jobseekers are strongly motivated
- Companies currently pay significant sums of money to recruiters and our
service is a fraction of the price, so we have a strong business model
- People are happy to be involved in a job network because they intuitively
understand that even if they are not looking for work or staff now that by
building a network it can be of use in the future
- Social networks reach across countries and even across borders, allowing
employers to reach out to jobseekers they could never afford to reach through
traditional media campaigns.
The current application, while still being improved, is already successfully
helping employers find staff and jobseekers find jobs. Click
here to see some feedback from customers.
A lot of the information you get from RealContacts is similar to what you might
get if you were to meet-up at a party with everyone you know, and the conversation
drifted onto job opportunities and which job might be right for which person.
The key things that make RealContacts a much more efficient way of transferring
this information are:
- You can find out not only about the jobs your direct contacts know about,
but also about jobs their contacts know about, and so on out to contacts up
to 4 degrees away from you.
- RealContacts shows details about a job position that someone telling you
about a position they know about wouldn't be likely to know, because the information
is coming directly from the source.
- RealContacts lets you see job opportunities without interrupting every other
person in the chain.
- You can set up notification so that as soon as a job is posted in your network
of contacts that matches your preferences you can find out about it, without
having to repeatedly visit and search on the website.
These features make RealContacts an extremely efficient way to find out about
job opportunities that never get advertised publicly. It is not a substitute
for real life networking; it just allows information to flow more easily between
people who already know and trust each other. By extending these links of trust,
RealContacts connects people who don't know each other directly through the
path of contacts they have in common, who can provide mutual endorsement or
advice if asked.
The Future of RealContacts
In the future you will be able to do a wide range of things using
RealContacts, not just find jobs or staff. Think of all the times you
place a higher value on information from your trusted network than from the
general public or companies you don't know, such as getting advice on
good (and bad) products and services, building teams and consortiums for
projects, and buying, selling, and trading goods and equipment, for
example. We are keen to work with people and companies on these new
applications. RealContacts is work in progress and we always welcome
suggestions on how to improve the service. Please contact us with your
thoughts and comments.
References (books, papers
and websites)
Albert-László
Barabási "Linked - The New Science of Networks" (Perseus
Publishing, 2002)
Duncan
J. Watts and Steven
H. Strogatz, "Collective Dynamics of "Small-World" Networks,"
Nature 393, 440-442 (1998)
Malcolm Gladwell, "The
Tipping Point," (Little, Brown, New York, 2000)
Mark
Buchanan, "Nexus - Small Worlds and the Groundbreaking Science of Networks"
(W.W. Norton and Company, 2002)
Mark
S. Granovetter, "The Strength of Weak Ties," American Journal
of Sociology 78, (1973) 1360-1380.
Stanley Milgram,
"The Small-World Problem," Psychology today 1, 60-67 (1967).
|